Industry News

Going DPC, a Colorado Practice Wrote Medicare Patients a Plan Guide

Piñon Family Practice in Littleton becomes Rocky Mountain DPC on Jan. 1, 2027. Its clinicians will opt out of Medicare, and its guide warns Medicare Advantage HMO members their plan may not work with the practice.

Policy Desk 4 min read Industry News

A worn wooden card file box of blank plastic insurance cards on a dark clinic front desk, lit blue from a window showing the silhouette of mountain foothills at dusk.

Piñon Family Practice in Littleton, Colo., will stop billing every insurer on Jan. 1, 2027. That includes commercial plans, Medicare, Medicare Advantage and health-share plans, according to a letter from Dr. Darcy Scheeler that the practice emailed to patients Oct. 10 to 13. The practice becomes Rocky Mountain Direct Primary Care, in the same office with the same clinicians.

The new practice’s site lists six of them: Scheeler, a board-certified family physician in private practice since 2003, plus four physician assistants and a family nurse practitioner. Membership is $150 a month for one adult, $225 for a couple and $300 for a parent or parents with children. The American Academy of Family Physicians says DPC fees “typically range from $50 to $100” a month. Current patients get first claim on spots, and pre-enrollment closes Nov. 30 “or when capacity is reached.”

What sets this conversion apart is the paperwork for Medicare patients. The practice published a two-page Medicare decision guide, dated October 2026, and linked it from its announcement.

The reason, in the practice’s words

In a Nov. 3 post, the practice apologized to patients who felt “unsettled, frustrated, and even anxious” about the news, and laid out the math behind it. “To remain financially sustainable under the traditional reimbursement model, our providers must average 20+ patient visits per day,” the post says. In an eight-hour day, it adds, that leaves 24 minutes per patient for check-in, the visit, documentation, orders and referrals.

The post also says “a large majority of our patients have high-deductible insurance plans,” often with deductibles larger than a year of membership. It doesn’t promise savings to everyone. “Some patients have excellent insurance benefits with very little out-of-pocket expense,” it says.

The practice says it can still order labs and imaging, refer to specialists and prescribe, and that outside services can still go to a patient’s insurance under the plan’s rules. It also says it “timed our announcement to coincide with the open enrollment period,” so patients could compare coverage first.

What opting out means for a Medicare patient

The guide says the practice’s providers “will opt out of Traditional Medicare” and will stop billing Medicare Advantage plans. A Medicare patient who joins signs “a separate Medicare private contract,” the guide says, “acknowledging that neither the patient nor RMDPC will bill Medicare.”

Federal rules set what that contract must say. Under 42 CFR 405.415, it has to be in writing. The patient accepts full responsibility for payment and agrees not to submit a claim to Medicare. The contract must also state that Medigap plans do not pay for those services. The opt-out rules reach past the physician. The regulation’s definition of “practitioner” includes physician assistants and nurse practitioners, so the same process applies to the five non-physician clinicians the site lists.

The timing rules are fixed too. Under 42 CFR 405.410, a participating physician may opt out at the beginning of any calendar quarter, if the affidavit reaches the Medicare contractor at least 30 days before that quarter starts. Jan. 1 starts a quarter. Each opt-out lasts two years and renews unless the clinician cancels it.

The guide then sorts patients by plan type:

  • Medicare Advantage HMO: “May not be compatible.” These plans “often require an in-network, designated PCP,” and may not recognize the practice’s orders or referrals.
  • Medicare Advantage PPO or Choice: “Potentially more flexible,” but patients should check with the plan first.
  • Original Medicare: “Works very well alongside RMDPC,” since it needs no designated PCP or approved referrals.

It also warns that switching to Original Medicare “does not guarantee that you can purchase a Medigap policy without underwriting,” and points patients to Colorado’s free Medicare counseling program.

The HSA line reaches only part of the panel

The practice’s single and family prices match federal limits exactly. For 2027, IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24 says a DPC arrangement doesn’t break HSA eligibility if aggregate monthly fees stay at or below $150, or $300 when the arrangement covers more than one person. The couples price, $225, sits under the $300 limit.

That pitch speaks to working-age patients on high-deductible plans. It doesn’t reach Medicare patients the same way. IRS Publication 969 lists “You aren’t enrolled in Medicare” among the conditions for contributing to an HSA.

What to watch

Four dates decide how many of Piñon’s patients follow it.

  • Nov. 30: pre-enrollment closes for current patients, unless the practice fills first. Neither the site nor the letters give a panel cap.
  • Dec. 7: Medicare open enrollment ends. Medicare.gov says a plan must get the request by then for coverage to start Jan. 1. This is the window to move from a Medicare Advantage HMO to Original Medicare or a PPO.
  • Jan. 1: the practice stops billing insurance. Ongoing care and prescription management there will require an active membership, the letter says.
  • March 31: the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period, which runs from Jan. 1 and covers only people already in a Medicare Advantage plan, ends. Until then, Medicare.gov says, those members can drop the plan and return to Original Medicare.

Sources

You might also like

The DPC news that matters, in 5 minutes.

DPC Insider breaks down direct primary care news, policy, and research so you can see what changed and why it matters.