AAFP's CEO Questions Whether Primary Care Belongs Inside Insurance
At a Nov. 12 National Academies meeting, AAFP CEO R. Shawn Martin said primary care may not need to sit inside a legacy insurance structure. He was on a panel discussing the report's proposed primary care common fund.
Policy Desk 4 min read Industry News
R. Shawn Martin runs the American Academy of Family Physicians. On Nov. 12 he told a National Academies panel he isn’t sure primary care needs to sit inside insurance the way it does now.
“I don’t know that primary care needs to sit inside an insurance structure in the traditional way that we’ve talked about here today,” Martin said, according to Medical Economics. “And I don’t know if the country is ready for that, but I think it’s a conversation that needs to be had.”
Martin is the executive vice president and CEO of the American Academy of Family Physicians, which says it represents 124,500 physicians and medical students. For DPC physicians, the sentence will sound familiar. The proposal he endorsed that day works differently from a DPC membership.
The common fund he was talking about
The meeting was an open session of the National Academies’ Standing Committee on Primary Care. It covered the new report, “Ensuring Access to High-Quality Primary Care in the United States.” The AAFP is one of the report’s sponsors, according to the National Academies.
Its central proposal is a common fund. The National Academies’ release describes a fund that would pool payments from public and private insurers to give universal, continuous coverage for primary care, whatever a person’s insurance status or plan. It would pay practices at standardized rates and eliminate cost-sharing for patients.
The report wants states to create these funds by law, with federal waivers to bring in Medicaid, ACA Marketplace plans and Medicare. As an alternative, Congress could create a federal fund run by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
Martin called the fund the right thing but said it was not necessarily ready for prime time, Medical Economics reported, because health regulation and payment are so complex. “I think big reforms come from big ideas that make people uncomfortable, and I think this is a big idea that makes a lot of people uncomfortable,” he said.
What the other panelists asked
Two analysts on the panel went straight to the mechanics. Zach Gaumer of the Bipartisan Policy Center asked how practices would be paid, whether under today’s physician fee schedule or through something new, such as a bundled payment like federally qualified health centers receive. “I think you need to figure out who’s going to pay for this,” he said.
Matthew Rae of KFF called the fund “a really interesting idea” because it addresses fragmentation, Medical Economics reported. He also said it raises questions about how it would interact with private insurance.
Rae said coverage still matters. KFF estimates about 14 million people will lose health insurance by 2034 because of Medicaid changes and the end of enhanced premium tax credits, according to the article. People who lose coverage are “about four times less likely to have a usual source of care,” he said.
Martin later clarified that people should still have health insurance.
Where the money stops
Martin’s broader complaint was about intermediaries. “I think we have just an enormous amount of financial intermediaries that are intercepting money in the healthcare system,” he said. He called cost-sharing “both an economic but also a behavioral disincentive to primary care” and said it should be removed.
He also wants much of the paperwork gone. “All the checklists on quality measures, all the utilization management stuff, like, a lot of that stuff just needs to go away,” he said.
Asked for one achievable policy, Martin suggested “something like a $75,000 above-the-line tax credit for five to 10 years for people that go into community-based primary care.”
Where DPC fits
DPC practices already take primary care out of insurance. The AAFP’s own policy on direct primary care describes periodic fees that “serve to replace the traditional system of third party insurance coverage for primary care services.” The same policy says most DPC patients, depending on affordability, still carry insurance for specialty care and hospital stays. That is close to the arrangement Martin described: primary care outside insurance, insurance still in place for the rest.
The two routes differ on who pays and who sets the price. In DPC, the patient pays a monthly or annual fee the practice charges. In the common-fund model, the fund pays participating practices a standardized rate, and the patient pays nothing at the visit. A DPC practice that wanted to take common-fund payments would have to accept a rate it did not choose.
None of this is close to law, and Martin’s remarks don’t change any rule a DPC practice works under today. The report asks states to pass legislation and HHS to grant waivers. On the panel, Gaumer suggested a state pilot of the fund first, along with better data on what care actually costs.
Sources
- Could a primary care common fund improve patient access and health? Analysts weigh in
- To Improve Access to Primary Care, New Report Calls for a Common Fund, Increased Investment, and Expanded Workforce
- Ensuring Access to High-Quality Primary Care in the United States (National Academies, 2026)
- PrimaryCare26 Introduces Triple Double Campaign to Strengthen Investment, Access and Workforce
- Direct Primary Care (AAFP policy)