Industry News

Brown Health Pledged More Primary Care. Its First Report Shows a Net Loss

Rhode Island's attorney general released Brown University Health's first progress report under its 2025 merger agreement: 14 primary care clinicians joined, 17 left, and four of the departures to concierge medicine.

Policy Desk 3 min read Industry News

A row of brass coat hooks on a dark plaster wall, a few holding folded white coats and the rest empty, with electric blue light glowing from the empty hooks.

Rhode Island let its largest hospital operator merge with Brown Physicians Inc. in 2025 in exchange for primary care growth mandates. The first progress report, released by Attorney General Peter Neronha, shows Brown University Health went the other way.

Seventeen primary care clinicians left the system’s medical group from October 2025, according to the performance report Brown submitted on July 1. Brown’s July 16 follow-up to the attorney general counted 14 arrivals through June 1. That is a net loss of three. It added 260 net new patients.

“I am deeply concerned by Brown Health’s insufficient progress, and in my view a repeat performance in the next reporting session would warrant a significant response from this Office,” Neronha said in a statement released with the report.

The deal behind the numbers

The commitments come from a September 2025 agreement. In exchange for them, Neronha suspended an antitrust review of the merger. The attorney general’s statement says the agreement requires up to 40,000 net new primary care patients and 15 net new primary care providers by Dec. 31, 2027.

Ocean State Media reported at the time that Brown would hire 27 primary care doctors over four years, and that Neronha could sue to reopen the antitrust investigation if the system fell short. Brown officials said the staffing would cost about $4 million more a year.

Rhode Island Current reported that the departing clinicians had been responsible for a combined 15,000 patients, which made adding new ones harder. The report itself says “nearly 15,000.”

There is real progress in the filing too. Brown cleared the waiting list that grew to 14,000 people after Anchor Medical Associates closed, the Current reported. Brown projected a net gain of four clinicians by Sept. 30.

Where the clinicians went

The report breaks down 22 departures, the 17 already gone plus five expected by year end. Eight moved out of state. Seven retired. Two went to another primary care organization and one was terminated. Four “moved to an external Concierge Medicine practice.”

The membership exits started early. Brown closed its Narragansett Family Medicine office in October 2025, after two physicians “left to open an independent concierge medicine practice in the fall 2025,” the report says. Brown kept about 2,300 of that practice’s patients, roughly 70% of the panel.

The attorney general’s office pressed on this point. In a follow-up request, it wrote that Brown had described “outflow to concierge medicine as physicians seek lower administrative burden and smaller panel sizes.” Brown’s redacted answer put it plainly. “For those clinicians departing to concierge medicine, the principal contributing factor is clinician preference to work at a slower pace associated with smaller panel sizes.”

The July 1 performance report gives the group’s average panels. Brown’s adult physicians average 1,766 patients per clinical full-time equivalent. Pediatric physicians average 1,339.

Brown’s own explanation ties the two problems together. The report blames “lower payor reimbursement in RI as compared to other states and the attraction of concierge medicine practices as a result.”

What the report can’t tell you

The documents say “concierge” every time. They don’t say whether the four clinicians’ new practices bill insurance or charge a membership fee alone. The American Academy of Family Physicians describes DPC as an alternative to fee-for-service insurance billing, with monthly fees that generally run $50 to $100. Costs vary by practice.

In October, DPC Insider covered Brown’s own $2,400-a-year premium primary care tier. Now the same system is telling the attorney general that membership practices are one reason its headcount fell.

Four of 22 departures is a minority. Relocation and retirement together account for 15. But smaller panels are now on the list by name, in a filing the attorney general asked for.

What to Watch

Neronha is term-limited. Kim Ahern won the race to succeed him, the Boston Globe reported.

Brown reports its progress to the attorney general twice a year, Ocean State Media reported when the deal was announced. The deadline for 15 net new providers is Dec. 31, 2027.

Sources

You might also like

The DPC news that matters, in 5 minutes.

DPC Insider breaks down direct primary care news, policy, and research so you can see what changed and why it matters.