Analysis

40% of Massachusetts Doctors Surveyed Have Weighed Concierge or DPC

A Boston Globe survey of 253 Massachusetts primary care doctors found 40% have considered leaving for concierge or direct primary care. The question put two very different models in one box.

Research Desk 4 min read Analysis

A wooden survey box on a dark table, folded paper slips spilling from its slot with a rose-pink glow from inside.

The Boston Globe asked 253 Massachusetts primary care doctors what is wrong with their jobs, and one question went straight at the exit door: “If you’re in the traditional primary care model, have you considered leaving it for concierge or direct primary care?”

Forty percent of the doctors said they had considered moving to an alternative model, if they hadn’t already made the move. The Globe published the results on Nov. 17, with Dr. Zirui Song, a professor of health care policy at Harvard Medical School, analyzing the responses.

That 40% is the number that will travel. It makes more sense once you know who answered and what the question asked them to picture.

Who answered

The Globe circulated the survey through professional groups, including the Massachusetts Medical Society and the Massachusetts Academy of Family Physicians. The methodology note gives no response rate, and the paper says it is still collecting answers for future articles and possible academic research.

So this is a convenience sample. Doctors with strong feelings about their work may be more likely to fill out a survey about why primary care is broken. The 40% describes these 253 respondents. It is not an estimate for every primary care doctor in the state.

The sample leans toward the big systems. About 59% of respondents worked for a health system, 28% for independent practices and 8% at community health centers. About 31% said their practice was owned by or affiliated with Mass General Brigham.

Within that group, the complaints were consistent. About 77% said they are overwhelmed by patient portal messages and clinical notes. Sixty-two percent cited too few clinicians, and 58% each named insurance paperwork and too many patients with complex conditions. Half named the corporatization of the practice environment.

Burnout tracks with the exit

The strongest pattern in the exit question was burnout. Nearly half of the doctors who said they were very burned out had considered leaving for a membership model. The Globe reports that doctors who did not feel burned out were far less likely to have thought about leaving.

DPC physicians give a related reason for the move they made. In the American Academy of Family Physicians’ 2026 data, 94% of DPC physicians cited more autonomy as a reason they chose the model.

Interest in leaving came with doubts. Among doctors who were considering an alternative model or had already left for one, 27% said they felt torn about the ethics of charging membership fees or about leaving their current patients.

One box, two models

The survey question put concierge and direct primary care side by side as a single option. The Globe described both together as models that “can charge annual fees, sometimes $10,000 or more, and offer on-demand care with far fewer patients per physician.”

AAFP draws the line between them more sharply. On its DPC page, it says DPC “usually involves lower monthly fees, does not bill insurance and covers a broader range of services,” while concierge medicine “often charges higher annual fees, may bill insurance for covered services and typically caters to higher-income populations.” It says monthly DPC fees “typically range from $50 to $100.” By our arithmetic, that is $600 to $1,200 over a year.

The system that the largest share of respondents named shows the concierge version. Mass General Brigham runs its own concierge program, and its page says the membership fee “does not cover the cost of the medical care delivered to you. Your insurance plan will cover the medical services.”

For a doctor deciding where to go, those are two different jobs. One keeps the insurance relationship and adds a fee on top. The other usually drops insurance billing and lives on the fee.

The two also pull on the ethics worry in different ways. A $10,000 annual fee limits a practice to patients who can pay it. A fee in AAFP’s range is lower, but it is still a fee, and the 27% who felt torn were answering about membership models as a group.

One quoted respondent shows how the frustration sounds from the other side. Dr. Amy Boutwell, identified by the Globe as a concierge doctor in Lexington, wrote that “the doctor actually works for the system, which works for/ tries to optimize payment from the insurance company, leaving the doctor and the patient and the clinical care structurally an afterthought.”

The open question

The survey cannot say which model the 40% had in mind. A doctor who pictured a concierge practice inside a Boston system and a doctor who pictured opening a solo DPC clinic gave the same answer. The published results do not split them.

It also cannot say how many respondents had already left, as opposed to considering it. The Globe’s wording, “if they hadn’t already made the leap,” folds both into the same figure. And it measures consideration, which is a long way from a signed lease or a resignation letter.

Those are the answers a health system or a state planner would need to estimate how many primary care doctors Massachusetts could lose, and to which model. The Globe says it is still collecting responses for future articles.

Sources

You might also like

The DPC news that matters, in 5 minutes.

DPC Insider breaks down direct primary care news, policy, and research so you can see what changed and why it matters.