Analysis

A National Academies Report Calls DPC's Small Panels a Drawback

The National Academies' 2026 primary care access report says DPC's low panel sizes reduce the effective supply of clinicians and increase disparities in access. The one study it cites for that counted practices and clinicians, not patients.

Research Desk 4 min read Analysis

A thick open bound report on a dark desk, with a thin rose-pink thread running from one of its pages to a slim closed journal several feet away.

A new National Academies report on access to primary care has a paragraph on direct primary care. That paragraph ends with a verdict: DPC “does, however, have a major system-level drawback: the low panel sizes reduce the effective supply of primary care clinicians available to serve the overall population and increase disparities in access to care.”

The report, Ensuring Access to High-Quality Primary Care in the United States, was released Nov. 5 as the five-year update to the National Academies’ 2021 primary care report. Medical Economics covered it on Nov. 10.

The report cites one study for that sentence.

What the report says about DPC

The DPC passage sits on page 39 of the prepublication copy, under a heading on changes in primary care since 2021. The committee calls DPC “one prominent market response” to problems with financing, workforce supply and administrative burden.

It then lays out the model in figures drawn from inside the DPC world:

  • An average subscription fee of $98 per member per month, from a national survey of DPC clinicians by the Direct Primary Care Alliance.
  • Average panels of 500 to 600 patients for DPC clinicians, against 1,700 for non-DPC clinicians, from the same Alliance survey.
  • Membership growth of more than 800 percent from 2017 to 2025, cited to Hint Health. The report adds that DPC “still remains a small proportion of primary care nationally.”

The committee also writes that DPC practices “are popular with patients who can afford it and with clinicians who value autonomy, less administrative hassle, and smaller patient panels.”

All three come from an advocacy group and a software vendor whose customers are DPC practices. A platform’s growth number describes its own book of business. The drawback claim does not rest on any of them.

The drawback sentence is cited to “Zhu et al., 2025.” The reference list on page 87 identifies it as a December 2025 Health Affairs paper by Jane Zhu and colleagues at Oregon Health & Science University, Johns Hopkins and Harvard.

What the cited study measured

The Zhu paper counted DPC and concierge practices together, using linked public and proprietary data. From 2018 to 2023, practice sites grew 83.1 percent and the clinicians working in them grew 78.4 percent. The physician share of those clinicians fell from 67.3 percent to 59.7 percent. Independent ownership fell from 84 percent to 59.7 percent.

About 60 percent of the clinicians in the sample took part in Medicare, which the authors read as a sign of concierge or hybrid practice. So most of the counted workforce was likely not insurance-free DPC at all.

The full text reports no panel sizes. It has no data on which patients these practices serve, their incomes or what care they lost or gained. Where smaller panels come up, the authors describe them as a feature these models share.

Its findings on where clinicians came from cut in more than one direction. Nearly 30 percent of physicians entering these practices came from health systems or integrated delivery networks. The authors found “relatively low rates” of entry from federally qualified health centers, the safety-net clinics that serve many uninsured and Medicaid patients. They offered two readings: structural barriers to leaving, or “the relative durability of the safety-net workforce.”

What holds up

The supply half of the sentence is mostly arithmetic. A clinician with 550 patients sees fewer people than one with 1,700. If that clinician would otherwise carry a full panel, the system loses capacity.

The disparity half is where the evidence thins. Showing that DPC increases disparities in access would take data on who left which panels, and who got care or lost it afterward. The cited paper does not collect it. Its own conclusion frames the stakes as a question, saying the findings bear on “the potential to mitigate broader primary care shortages instead of compounding them.”

The DPC paragraph is a small part of a long report. The committee’s main recommendations go elsewhere: a state common fund that would provide universal coverage for primary care, and a push to raise primary care to at least 10 percent of total health spending, according to the report highlights. Medical Economics reported that the committee was skeptical that market responses alone, DPC among them, will close the gap.

What nobody has counted

Nothing the report cites answers the question at the center of that sentence. It would need to follow clinicians who move into DPC and ask where they would otherwise practice. Some might stay in insurance-based primary care, some might leave it, and some might cut hours. It would also need to track what happens to the patients on the panels they left.

The Zhu paper’s authors said as much. Its last sentence calls the effect of concierge and DPC models “on access to care, quality of care, and the primary care workforce” something that “will be vital for patients, clinicians, and policy makers to understand.”

The report’s drawback sentence cites that paper and no other.

Sources

You might also like

The DPC news that matters, in 5 minutes.

DPC Insider breaks down direct primary care news, policy, and research so you can see what changed and why it matters.