Medicare's Monthly Primary Care Bundle Hits a Copay Problem
A Primary Care Collaborative report on 2025 claims finds Medicare's APCM bundle reached 1.2% of fee-for-service patients in the fourth quarter, and 42% of survey respondents ranked collecting the $3 to $10 monthly copay as the top hurdle.
Research Desk 4 min read Analysis
About 344,000 people in traditional Medicare got Advanced Primary Care Management services in the last quarter of 2025. That is 1.2% of Medicare’s fee-for-service patients, according to a report from the Primary Care Collaborative and West Health Policy Center published Oct. 29.
APCM is Medicare’s monthly bundle for primary care. Since Jan. 1, 2025, a practice can bill one code a month per patient for care management between visits, with no time tracking, in exchange for 24/7 access, a care plan and patient consent. DPC Insider covered how it works in April. The new report is the first full look at how the first year went, and the main problem it names will sound familiar to anyone who charges a membership fee.
What the first year looked like
The report analyzed 2025 Medicare fee-for-service claims, surveyed the PCC’s community and ran five case studies of early adopters. The full report counts 2.49 million beneficiary-months and $130.7 million in allowed spending for the year, billed by 9,748 clinicians across 1,951 billing entities. Volume grew 2.7-fold from the first quarter to the fourth.
Most of that growth came from newcomers. Nearly two-thirds of the added volume came from clinicians who were not billing APCM in the first quarter. Between 12% and 16% of billing clinicians stopped from one quarter to the next, and the report says that turnover raises difficulties in projecting the program’s long-term impact.
The report calls the reach modest and expects APCM spending to “remain extremely small” against total Medicare spending.
The monthly copay
APCM is a Part B service. A patient without supplemental coverage owes coinsurance every month the practice bills, about $3 for Level 1 and $10 for Level 2, the report says. Qualified Medicare Beneficiaries, a low-income group also eligible for Medicaid, pay nothing. The report puts the share of standard beneficiaries with no supplemental coverage at 13%.
That small charge was the hurdle respondents ranked first most often. In the PCC’s survey of 176 respondents, fielded from July 16 to Aug. 6, 2026, 42% ranked collecting the monthly cost-sharing as the biggest hurdle. Asked for the one change that would most help adoption, 54% picked waiving copays for patients without supplemental coverage while holding practices harmless.
Alex Krist, a family physician who co-leads APCM implementation at Inova Primary Care in Northern Virginia, called the cost-sharing a “massive problem” in the report.
“I think with the co-payment we could get 30-40% of our patients to sign up. If they had no co-payment, I think we could get 80-90% of our patients to sign up,” Krist said.
His practice found that patients often agree once they hear the program pays for more staff. “But it creates this conflict and makes the clinicians feel like they are selling something to their patients,” he said.
Jason Lofton runs an independent rural practice in De Queen, Ark. The report says some of his patients balk at owing money in months when they had no visit. “I’m real upfront,” Lofton said. “I tell the patients about what the payment is, how it helps us, how it can help them.”
Why a DPC reader might care
A DPC membership is a flat periodic fee that does not depend on visits. The AAFP says DPC fees typically range from $50 to $100 a month. APCM’s patient share is a small fraction of that, and it still led the list of hurdles.
Some practices in the report answered it by explaining the fee. Lofton tells patients what the payment buys. Krist’s team tells patients it lets the practice hire more staff. The PCC’s own survey found that a plurality of respondents, 42%, ranked “regular monthly revenue to support previously unpaid care such as after-hours coverage” as APCM’s top benefit.
The counterargument
The strongest case against reading this as a lesson about monthly fees comes from a second study. A survey in the Journal of General Internal Medicine, fielded in December 2025, asked a convenience sample of 404 primary care clinicians about the codes. Only 14.9% used them. Another 43.6% had never heard of them. Among the 168 who named a specific barrier, the top administrative ones were not understanding the documentation, at 53.0%, and EHR problems, at 38.1%.
In that sample, more clinicians had never heard of the codes than named any barrier at all. The two surveys asked different people different questions, and the PCC’s respondents were people already familiar with APCM. Neither can measure how patients themselves decide.
The patient’s position is also different. In traditional Medicare, the APCM charge arrives as cost-sharing on coverage the patient already has, and some of Lofton’s patients were unclear why they owed money in a month with no visit. A DPC patient chooses to subscribe, as the AAFP puts it. That gap is real, and it means the APCM numbers can’t predict how many people will pay a DPC membership.
What survives is narrower. Among the PCC’s survey respondents, the patient’s monthly share was the hurdle ranked first most often, and some of the clinicians in the case studies handled it by explaining what the fee pays for in the months without a visit. Waiving that share would take congressional action, the report says, citing the 2025 Medicare final rule. Its broadest suggestion, as Medical Economics reported, is for Congress to designate APCM services as preventive, as it did for the Annual Wellness Visit.
Sources
- APCM: Ensuring the Bundled Payment Delivers Better Health
- Advanced Primary Care Management: Ensuring the Bundled Payment Delivers Better Health (full report PDF)
- Primary Care Clinician Uptake of Medicare Advanced Primary Care Management Billing Codes
- First look at APCM data: Growth, modest reach, physician turnover for Medicare's primary care bundle
- Direct Primary Care (AAFP)