A South Carolina DPC Practice Runs Its Own MRI, With Posted Prices
Palmetto Proactive, a direct primary care practice in Upstate South Carolina, runs a self-pay imaging center in Spartanburg. It lists member MRI prices starting at $480 and takes outside referrals.
Practice Desk 4 min read Practice Spotlight
When a member of Palmetto Proactive needs an MRI, the direct primary care practice can send them to an imaging center it runs in Spartanburg, S.C. Its website lists what a member pays before the scan. The practice also has clinics in Greenville and Cayce.
The practice lists member starting prices of $480 for an MRI, $300 for a CT scan, $80 for an X-ray, $125 for a coronary calcium score and $300 for a low-dose lung cancer screening. A note under the list says prices may vary and that the figures are “member starting prices with discounts applied.” The center does not bill insurance.
The center appears in a Gray Media segment that WSMV published on Nov. 6, about patients who choose self-pay alternatives to medical insurance.
What the TV report found
The segment followed DJ Horton, who took his son to Palmetto Proactive’s imaging center for a knee MRI after sports pain. Because the family holds a Palmetto Proactive membership, the report said, they paid about $350 to $400 per knee. It put the practice’s usual non-member price at $500 to $600.
For comparison, the report said hospital systems in the area charge about $2,000 cash for a leg MRI, and that a patient who uses insurance before meeting the deductible can pay around $3,500. Those are the segment’s figures, not a published hospital price list.
The report’s member price sits below the $480 starting price the practice posts today. The segment carries a 2025 copyright line, and one family in it described an MRI from fall 2024, so its figures may predate the current page.
Dr. Chris McCarthy of Palmetto Proactive compared the model to a subscription service in the segment. He said patients can often get same-day appointments and more time with their doctor.
How the pieces fit together
The membership and the scanner are priced separately. On its individual plan page, Palmetto Proactive says its primary care membership starts at $80 per month per adult and covers sick visits, annual physicals and chronic disease management with no copays for covered office visits. It says labs, procedures and imaging “may be available at included or discounted rates depending on the service and location.”
The imaging center is open to people who never join. Its page says it welcomes patients “who are not Palmetto Proactive members” and accepts orders from outside physicians. A physician referral is required for every scan, and self-referrals are not accepted. The equipment is a 1.5T wide-bore MRI, plus CT and X-ray, and the center runs weekdays by appointment.
That makes the scanner a second line of business with two kinds of customer. A member gets a discount on a cash price. A non-member pays a cash price at a center that, by its own description, will not send a claim to their insurer. The page posts member prices only.
The employer page describes the arrangement more broadly. It lists imaging among the services the clinical team handles “within the membership” for companies that buy DPC for their staff. The individual page says discounted or included rates. The two pages are written for different buyers, and neither publishes an employer contract.
The open question
Since Jan. 1, an HSA can pay for a DPC membership under federal law, and IRS Notice 2026-5 sets out what counts as a direct primary care service arrangement. Two of its answers bear on a practice that sells something besides the membership.
Answer 11 says the fixed periodic fee must be the sole compensation for care provided under the arrangement. An arrangement that provides items and services on the condition of membership but bills separately for them does not qualify.
Answer 12 covers the other side. A practice whose arrangement otherwise qualifies may offer items and services outside the arrangement “regardless of membership” and bill both members and non-members for them separately. The notice answers that one yes.
Palmetto Proactive’s imaging center sells to members and non-members, which is the fact pattern in Answer 12. The member discount is the part the notice does not reach. It does not say whether a lower price offered only to members keeps a separately billed service outside the arrangement, or ties it to membership in the way Answer 11 describes.
Fee size is a separate test. The notice’s own example puts the 2026 limit for an individual at $1,800 a year, and the practice’s adult fee starts at $80 a month, well under it. None of the practice’s plan or imaging pages says how it reads Answers 11 and 12.