Practice Spotlight

Bellows Falls Lost Its Health Center. A DPC Practice Wants to Talk.

Nearly two years after North Star Health closed its Rockingham clinic, the nonprofit that runs Bellows Falls' old hospital building says Blue Spruce Health, a Vermont direct primary care group, is interested in the space.

Practice Desk 3 min read Practice Spotlight

A brass key with a paper tag rests on the stone sill of a tall, dark hospital window, with green light glowing from an empty room behind the glass.

“I am pleased to announce we have a possible primary care option,” Marty Gallagher told the Rockingham, Vt., Selectboard on Nov. 3. “It is called Direct Primary Care. The entity that is interested in coming and talking with us is Blue Spruce Health.”

Gallagher runs Greater Rockingham Area Services, the nonprofit that maintains the buildings and grounds at 1 Hospital Court in Bellows Falls, the town’s old hospital. The Vermont Journal reported that the group had been looking for a tenant to fill the space left when North Star Health moved out.

No agreement has been announced. Blue Spruce has agreed to talk, and the two sides have a schedule for doing it this month.

The clinic that left

North Star Health is a federally qualified health center with sites in Vermont and New Hampshire. It ran the Rockingham Health Center in the old hospital until Jan. 1, 2025, when it consolidated the clinic into its Springfield, Vt., and Charlestown, N.H., locations.

North Star said the number of primary care patients at Rockingham had fallen by nearly 50% since 2020. VTDigger reported that administrators also blamed staffing shortages, aging buildings and low insurer payments for primary care. “The Rockingham Health Center was the most expensive to operate and we must prioritize long-term sustainability in delivering high quality care,” CEO Joshua Dufresne said in a statement to VTDigger.

Patients could follow their provider to another North Star site. Local reaction at the time centered on the drive. “If you live in Bellows Falls, you shouldn’t have to drive 10 or 15 miles to go see a doctor,” patient John Gregg told VTDigger. Selectboard chair Rick Cowan wrote at the time that the closing left the town’s most vulnerable residents without access, “since many of the clinic’s patients don’t own cars.”

VTDigger reported then that local officials were trying to find another medical provider for the building. The candidate interested now, about 22 months later, charges a monthly membership fee that covers in-office care.

Who Blue Spruce is

Blue Spruce Health is a direct primary care group with offices in Newport, St. Johnsbury and Williston, according to its website.

Its website lists monthly membership prices by age:

  • $100 for members 26 and under, with an adult member
  • $150 for adults 27 to 59
  • $175 for members 60 and older

DPC Insider covered Blue Spruce’s growth in April, when a Seven Days feature profiled it among several Vermont DPC practices.

The model changes the math North Star described. A membership practice is paid by its patients each month instead of by insurers per visit, so low insurer payments stop being its problem. Patient count stays its problem. North Star’s clinic lost nearly half its primary care patients after 2020, and a DPC practice has to sign up enough people willing to pay a monthly fee on top of whatever coverage they carry. The Journal’s report doesn’t say how many members Blue Spruce would need at the site, or what it would charge there.

What to watch

Gallagher gave each board member a handout on the group and asked that a selectboard member join a Zoom meeting set for Nov. 12, according to the Vermont Journal.

The selectboard meets next on Nov. 17 at 6 p.m. in the lower theater of Rockingham Town Hall.

On Nov. 19, Blue Spruce plans to come to Rockingham for what Gallagher described as a “meet and greet and a question-and-answer session so they can get to know us, [and] we can get to know them and make sure that it would potentially be a good fit.”

Sources

You might also like

The DPC news that matters, in 5 minutes.

DPC Insider breaks down direct primary care news, policy, and research so you can see what changed and why it matters.