Massachusetts Primary Care Reform Runs Into ERISA, the AG's Report Says
For one large Massachusetts insurer, 64% of 2024 primary care visits were in self-insured plans, which the attorney general says are exempt from most state insurance rules. The state's pending DPC bill is written mostly into state insurance law.
Policy Desk 5 min read Legislation
For one large commercial insurer in Massachusetts, 64% of 2024 primary care visits were for members of self-insured plans. That figure comes from the 2026 Health Care Cost Trends Report that Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell’s office released on Nov. 10. Self-insured plans, the report says, “are regulated by the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and are exempt from most state insurance regulations.”
That sentence bears on the direct primary care bill still pending in the Massachusetts House. The bill protects referrals made by doctors outside an insurer’s network, and it does that mostly by amending state insurance law.
What the attorney general measured
The report is mostly about money. The office used 2024 data from a sample of commercial insurers and ten provider organizations, among them Mass General Brigham, Beth Israel Lahey Health, Tufts Medicine and Optum. Among its findings:
- Commercial insurers paid $489 million in supplemental payments across all services in 2024. These are incentive, infrastructure, shared savings and other payments not tied to a claim. Core primary care fee-for-service payments came to $1.6 billion.
- Most of that supplemental money went to a few large systems. At Tufts Medicine, supplemental payments equaled 87% of core primary care fee-for-service payments.
- Contracted commercial rates for the same primary care services ranged from 127% to 244% of Medicare across the providers studied. The two lowest, Signature Healthcare and Community Care Cooperative, served higher shares of Medicaid patients.
- Nine of the ten organizations estimated that they passed between 22% and 48% of their supplemental payments on to primary care providers. One reported passing on none.
The self-insured finding is the one with a direct line to DPC policy. Across the study providers, the self-insured share of that insurer’s primary care visits ranged from 58% to 89%. The report says the spread is likely explained at least in part by specific large employers that use the insurer to administer their plans.
Its conclusion on what that means for state policy is blunt: “federal preemption limits the state’s ability to mandate market-wide adoption of new commercial primary care payment models through legislation.”
What the bill changes
The DPC bill began as H.1343, filed by Rep. Thomas P. Walsh of Peabody. On Feb. 5, 2026, the Joint Committee on Financial Services replaced it with a new draft, H.5022, reported it favorably and sent it to the Joint Committee on Health Care Financing. On July 9 that committee’s reporting date was extended to Dec. 31, 2026.
The title is “An Act relative to direct primary care,” but the phrase does not appear in the bill text itself. Its central sentence appears seven times, each added to a different chapter of state law. An eighth section writes a rule with a different subject, blanket and general policies, into one more chapter. The repeated sentence reads: “A carrier may not deny payment for any health care service covered under an enrollee’s health plan based solely on the basis that the enrollee’s referral was made by a provider who is not a member of the carrier’s provider network.”
A DPC physician who does not contract with an insurer is outside its network, so a referral from that physician is the kind the bill protects. Those eight sections would apply to contracts entered into, renewed or amended one year after the act takes effect.
The AG’s numbers show how far that protection could carry. The bill writes its rule into state law, and the report describes self-insured plans as exempt from most state insurance regulations. For the one insurer the AG examined in detail, those plans covered 64% of primary care visits.
The draft also loosens the state’s limits on physicians dispensing controlled substances. It strikes the rule that a dispensed amount may not exceed what a patient needs until a pharmacy can fill a prescription. That change amends the controlled substances chapter and does not depend on any carrier.
Where membership medicine shows up in the report
DPC appears once, in a footnote. The report’s introduction says “New concierge models are emerging that offer primary care providers higher pay and smaller patient panels, but they are available only to patients able to pay significant fees.” The footnote cites a 2025 Health Affairs study reporting an 83.1% increase in concierge and direct primary care clinicians, and Mass General Brigham’s concierge page, which the AG notes lists a $10,000 annual membership fee.
That puts DPC next to a price far above what the model usually charges. The American Academy of Family Physicians says monthly DPC membership fees generally range from $50 to $100. The report does not separate the two models. Its payment data come from insurance claims and from supplemental payments made by insurers.
The case that the bill aims at the right plans
The strongest defense of H.5022 comes from the same report. A referral rule matters most where a plan requires referrals. The AG explains that HMO and POS plans require patients to select a primary care provider to coordinate care, while PPO and EPO plans generally do not require a primary care selection or a referral to see specialists.
For the insurer the AG examined, most fully insured primary care visits were in HMO and POS plans. A significant share of the self-insured visits were in PPO or EPO plans, where a referral generally is not required. So for part of the self-insured population the bill may not reach, a referral rule may matter less.
That defense covers self-insured PPO members. It says nothing about self-insured HMO and POS members, and the report’s text does not give their share. The AG also offered a route around the gap: addressing advanced primary care mandates to providers rather than to insurers or plan sponsors, which would reach all segments of the market. H.5022 takes the insurer route, and its committee deadline is Dec. 31.
Sources
- AG Campbell Issues 2026 Health Care Cost Trends Report Examining Primary Care Payments (Massachusetts Attorney General's Office, Nov. 10, 2026)
- Examination of Health Care Cost Trends 2026 (Massachusetts Attorney General's Office)
- Bill H.5022, An Act relative to direct primary care (Massachusetts Legislature)
- H.5022 bill text (Massachusetts Legislature)
- Bill H.1343, An Act relative to direct primary care (Massachusetts Legislature)
- Direct Primary Care (American Academy of Family Physicians)